Cardiff Surveyors assess structural movement and cracking in properties across South Wales daily. One of the most common concerns raised by homebuyers during property surveys is cracking to walls – and understandably so. Cracks can indicate serious structural problems requiring tens of thousands of pounds to rectify, or they might be harmless cosmetic issues needing simple decoration.
As RICS chartered surveyors and building surveyors with decades of combined experience across Cardiff, Penarth, Newport, and throughout South Wales, we've developed expertise in assessing structural movement, identifying its causes, and advising on appropriate remedial action. This comprehensive guide explains what structural movement is, what causes it in Cardiff properties, how we assess it, and what solutions exist.
Understanding Structural Movement
All buildings move. The question is whether movement is within acceptable tolerances or indicates problems requiring intervention. Structural movement occurs when the building's foundation, walls, or roof structure shift from their original position, typically manifesting as cracking, distortion, or displacement.
Types of Structural Movement
Cardiff Surveyors categorizes structural movement into several types:
Subsidence: Downward movement of foundations caused by ground beneath losing volume, typically through clay shrinkage, ground water removal, or undermining.
Settlement: Downward movement as the ground consolidates under the building's weight. Initial settlement is normal in new buildings. Differential settlement (where one part of the building settles more than another) causes problems.
Heave: Upward movement of foundations, typically caused by clay soils swelling as they absorb moisture after trees are removed.
Lateral Movement: Horizontal displacement, often caused by inadequate support, external loads, or loss of restraint (e.g., missing wall ties in cavity walls).
Thermal Movement: Expansion and contraction due to temperature changes, particularly affecting roofs, long walls, and materials like concrete.
Moisture Movement: Expansion when materials absorb moisture and contraction when they dry out, particularly affecting timber, brick, and stone.
Common Causes of Structural Movement in Cardiff Properties
Clay Soil Subsidence
Cardiff and much of South Wales sits on varied geology including clay soils that shrink when they dry and swell when saturated. Periods of prolonged dry weather cause clay to lose moisture and volume, leading to subsidence. Factors exacerbating clay subsidence include:
- Tree roots: Large trees (particularly willows, oaks, poplars, and ashes) near properties extract vast amounts of moisture from clay, causing shrinkage and subsidence
- Leaking drains: Can wash away supporting soil beneath foundations
- Climate change: Increasingly hot, dry summers in recent years have elevated subsidence claims across Cardiff
- Inadequate foundations: Victorian and Edwardian properties often have shallow foundations (sometimes only 300-600mm deep) vulnerable to clay movement
Areas of Cardiff with significant clay content where our building surveyors regularly encounter subsidence include Roath, Cathays, Heath, Birchgrove, and Rhiwbina.
Mining and Ground Instability
The South Wales valleys have extensive coal mining history. While Cardiff city center wasn't directly mined, surrounding areas (Caerphilly, Pontypridd, valleys extending north) have historical workings. Abandoned mines can cause:
- Crown hole collapses where shallow mine workings collapse to surface
- Gradual settlement as voids consolidate
- Ground instability affecting foundations
Coal Authority reports should be obtained for properties in affected areas. Our Cardiff Surveyors building surveys always recommend coal mining searches where appropriate.
Poor Building Techniques and Alterations
Structural movement often results from poor construction or inappropriate alterations:
- Inadequate foundation depth or width
- Removal of load-bearing walls without proper support
- Lintel failures above windows and doors
- Wall tie failure in cavity walls (particularly houses built 1920s-1980s)
- Roof spread where roof structure pushes walls outward
- Poorly executed extensions with inadequate foundations
Water-Related Issues
Water causes numerous structural problems:
- Leaking drains undermining foundations
- Blocked or inadequate rainwater disposal saturating ground
- Rising ground water levels affecting foundations
- Frost damage to brickwork and masonry
Tree Root Damage
This deserves particular emphasis for Cardiff properties. Victorian and Edwardian terraces often have mature trees nearby. Tree roots cause subsidence through:
- Direct action: Roots physically pushing against foundations
- Indirect action: Extracting moisture from clay, causing shrinkage and subsidence (more common)
Trees requiring particular caution include willows, poplars, oaks, ash, elm, plane, and eucalyptus. As a guide, trees should be no closer than their mature height to properties. A mature oak reaching 20 meters high should be at least 20 meters from the property.
Types of Cracking and What They Indicate
Not all cracks indicate serious problems. Cardiff Surveyors assesses cracks based on several characteristics:
Crack Width Classification
The Building Research Establishment (BRE) classification system categorizes damage by crack width:
- Category 0 (Hairline, less than 0.1mm): Negligible, aesthetic only
- Category 1 (Up to 1mm): Very slight, easily filled during decoration
- Category 2 (Up to 5mm): Slight, visible cracks that can be easily filled. Repointing of external brickwork may be required
- Category 3 (5-15mm or multiple cracks 3mm+): Moderate damage. Repointing and possibly patching of render required. Doors and windows may stick. Weatherproofing impaired
- Category 4 (15-25mm, depending on positions): Severe damage requiring extensive repair. Windows and doors stick. Weatherproofing significantly impaired. Structural stability affected
- Category 5 (Greater than 25mm): Very severe damage requiring major reconstruction. Stability at risk
Our building surveys always measure crack widths and photograph them with scale references.
Crack Patterns and What They Mean
Diagonal stepped cracking following mortar joints: Typically indicates subsidence, settlement, or heave. Direction of steps can indicate which part of the wall has moved.
Vertical cracks: May indicate thermal or moisture movement, lintel failure, or differential settlement.
Horizontal cracks: Can indicate wall tie failure, roof spread, or lateral pressure from retained earth.
Tapered cracks (wide at top, narrow at bottom or vice versa): Strongly suggests active structural movement. Width variation indicates direction of movement.
Uniform width cracks: Often thermal or moisture movement rather than subsidence.
Cracks around windows and doors: May indicate lintel failure, subsidence, or just minor settlement.
How Cardiff Surveyors Assess Structural Movement
When our RICS chartered surveyors identify cracking during building surveys, we follow systematic assessment procedures:
Visual Inspection and Measurement
- Measure crack widths with crack gauges
- Photograph all significant cracks with scale references
- Map crack patterns throughout the property
- Assess whether cracks are historic (old, stable, painted over) or recent/active
- Check for associated distortion (sloping floors, out-of-plumb walls, sticking doors/windows)
External Factors Assessment
- Identify nearby trees (species, size, proximity to property)
- Assess ground levels and drainage (ponding water, inadequate falls)
- Check for visible subsidence to paths, driveways, or boundary walls
- Inspect neighboring properties for similar cracking patterns
- Consider soil type and local geology
Internal Investigations
- Check floors for levelness (spirit levels, laser levels)
- Assess walls for plumb (are they vertical or leaning?)
- Inspect roof space for evidence of roof spread or structural inadequacy
- Check for damp which might indicate leaking drains
- Review any visible foundations (in basements, where exposed)
Documentation Review
- Request any previous structural reports from the seller
- Check whether underpinning or structural repairs have been completed
- Review building regulation certificates for extensions
- Check historical photos if available
Monitoring Structural Movement
When Cardiff Surveyors identifies cracking that may indicate active movement but isn't immediately catastrophic, monitoring is often recommended before expensive repairs:
Tell-Tale Crack Monitors
Simple plastic or glass strips glued across cracks. If movement continues, the tell-tale cracks or shows displacement. Cheap (£10-20 each) and effective for 6-12 month monitoring periods.
Precise Levelling
Structural engineers establish precise datum points and measure floor levels periodically to detect ongoing settlement or heave.
Photographic Records
Dated photographs of cracks allow comparison over time. Measuring and marking crack ends helps identify any extension.
Monitoring typically runs for 12 months covering seasonal cycles (wet winter, dry summer) to determine whether movement is ongoing or historic.
Repair Solutions for Structural Movement
Underpinning
The traditional solution for subsidence involves excavating beneath existing foundations in stages and casting deeper concrete foundations. Types include:
Mass concrete underpinning: Sequential excavation and concrete filling beneath existing foundations. Cost: £1,000-£1,500 per meter run, so £15,000-£30,000+ for affected walls.
Piled underpinning: Driving or casting concrete piles to stable ground below, then connecting to existing structure. Suitable for deeper instability or restricted access. Cost: £20,000-£50,000+.
Resin injection: Modern alternative involving injecting expanding resin beneath foundations to stabilize and compact ground. Less disruptive than traditional underpinning. Cost: £10,000-£25,000 typically.
Structural Repairs
Wall tie replacement: For cavity wall tie failure, specialist contractors install new ties. Cost: £40-60 per square meter, so £3,000-£8,000 for typical Cardiff terraced house.
Lintel replacement/installation: Installing or replacing failed lintels above openings. Cost: £500-£1,500 per opening depending on size and access.
Roof tie-rods: Installing steel rods to prevent roof spread. Cost: £2,000-£5,000.
Crack stitching and grouting: Stainless steel bars grouted into cracks to stabilize masonry. Cost: £1,500-£4,000 depending on extent.
Tree Management
Where trees cause subsidence:
- Tree removal: Eliminates future risk but can cause heave as soil rehydrates. Cost: £500-£3,000 depending on size
- Pruning: Reduces canopy and water uptake. Ongoing maintenance required. Cost: £300-£1,000 per session
- Root barriers: Physical barriers limiting root extension toward property. Cost: £2,000-£5,000
Drainage Repairs
Leaking drains must be repaired to prevent ongoing undermining. Modern no-dig lining technology allows drainage repair without excavation. Cost: £1,500-£5,000 depending on extent.
Insurance Claims for Subsidence
Buildings insurance typically covers subsidence (but not settlement or normal thermal/moisture movement). Key points:
- Large excesses apply (typically £1,000-£2,500 for subsidence claims)
- Insurers will investigate thoroughly, including soil analysis and monitoring
- Claims can take 1-2 years to resolve
- Future insurance premiums often increase significantly
- Properties with subsidence history may face insurance difficulties when selling
Buying Property with Structural Movement
Cardiff Surveyors regularly surveys properties with evidence of historic or current structural movement. Our advice to buyers:
Questions to Ask
- Has the property suffered subsidence or structural damage?
- Have repairs been carried out? Obtain warranties/guarantees
- Was insurance involved? Obtain claim details and settlement documentation
- Is there a monitoring program? Review data
- Are there still trees that caused original damage?
Mortgage Implications
Lenders are extremely cautious regarding structural movement:
- Active movement: Most lenders refuse to lend
- Historic movement, professionally repaired with guarantees: Usually acceptable with appropriate documentation
- Monitoring programs: Lenders typically wait for 12-month monitoring completion before lending
Negotiating Price
If our survey identifies structural movement requiring repair:
- Obtain structural engineer's report and repair quotes
- Negotiate purchase price reduction to cover repair costs plus contingency
- Consider residual value impact even after repairs (typically 5-10% reduction)
- Factor in stress, disruption, and time lost during repair works
Frequently Asked Questions
How do I know if cracks in my Cardiff property are serious?
Width, pattern, and location determine severity. Cracks over 5mm wide, diagonal stepped cracking, tapered cracks, or cracks appearing suddenly require professional assessment. Cardiff Surveyors provides RICS building surveys that include detailed crack analysis with measurements, photographs, and advice on whether structural engineer investigation is needed. Don't ignore significant cracking – early intervention prevents expensive problems.
How much does underpinning cost in Cardiff?
Traditional mass concrete underpinning costs £1,000-£1,500 per linear meter. Typical Cardiff terraced house requiring two walls underpinned might cost £15,000-£30,000. Piled underpinning for severe instability costs £20,000-£50,000+. Modern resin injection underpinning costs £10,000-£25,000. Costs depend on access, foundation depth required, ground conditions, and property type. Always obtain multiple quotes from specialist underpinning contractors.
Can I claim on insurance for subsidence?
Buildings insurance covers subsidence (downward movement due to ground beneath losing volume) but typically not settlement (consolidation under weight) or normal thermal/moisture movement. Subsidence claims have large excesses (£1,000-£2,500 typically) and insurers investigate thoroughly, often requiring 12-month monitoring before approving repairs. Claims impact future premiums and property insurability when selling.
Should I buy a property that has been underpinned?
Professionally underpinned properties can be perfectly acceptable purchases if: repairs were carried out by reputable contractors; insurance-backed guarantees exist and are transferable; monitoring confirms no ongoing movement; and the cause (e.g., leaking drain, tree roots) has been addressed. However, expect 5-10% reduced value compared to similar properties without subsidence history, and some mortgage lenders remain cautious. Cardiff Surveyors always reviews underpinning documentation during building surveys.
Do I need a structural engineer or can a surveyor assess movement?
RICS chartered surveyors (like Cardiff Surveyors) can assess most structural movement and advise whether it's minor, moderate, or severe. For significant cracking, active movement, or when underpinning may be required, we recommend commissioning specialist structural engineers who can design repair solutions and provide detailed calculations. Our building surveys identify issues and advise when structural engineer input is necessary.
How long does structural movement monitoring take?
Typically 12 months covering full seasonal cycle (wet winter/spring, dry summer/autumn). This allows assessment of clay soil shrink/swell cycles and tree root impact across growing seasons. In some cases, particularly where insurance claims are involved or movement patterns are unclear, monitoring extends to 18-24 months. Monitoring provides evidence of whether movement is ongoing (requiring intervention) or historic/stable (requiring only cosmetic repair).
What trees cause most subsidence problems in Cardiff?
High water demand trees causing frequent subsidence in Cardiff include: willows, poplars, oaks, ash, elms, planes, eucalyptus, and large conifers. As general rule, trees should be no closer to properties than their mature height. Victorian/Edwardian Cardiff properties often have mature trees nearby on clay soils – a common subsidence cause. Our building surveys always assess tree proximity and species when investigating structural movement.
Conclusion: Professional Assessment is Essential
Structural movement and cracking in Cardiff properties ranges from harmless cosmetic issues to serious defects requiring tens of thousands of pounds in repairs. The difference isn't always obvious to untrained eyes, making professional RICS building surveys essential when buying property.
Cardiff Surveyors' building surveyors have decades of combined experience assessing structural movement across Cardiff, Penarth, Newport, and throughout South Wales. We understand local soil conditions, typical construction methods in Victorian and Edwardian properties, and regional factors affecting structural stability.
Our RICS Level 2 and Level 3 building surveys include comprehensive assessment of any structural movement or cracking, with detailed measurements, photographs, explanations of likely causes, and clear advice on necessary actions – from simple monitoring to urgent structural engineer investigation.
If you're buying property in Cardiff or South Wales and notice cracking or have concerns about structural movement, commission comprehensive RICS building survey before committing to purchase. The cost (£550-£1,200 typically) is minimal compared to potential subsidence repair bills of £15,000-£50,000+.
For homeowners concerned about cracking in properties they already own, Cardiff Surveyors provides specific defect surveys focusing on structural assessment, helping you understand whether problems require intervention or can be safely monitored.
Concerned About Structural Cracking?
Our RICS chartered surveyors provide expert structural movement assessment across Cardiff and South Wales. Professional surveys identify serious issues and save you from expensive mistakes.
Book Your Building Survey